SEE LATEST ESSAYS Jurisprudence and legal theory essays

The courts play a more important role in shaping the content of the law

Essay Barrister
November 03, 2026
No comments
Jurisprudence - a desk with two people arguing and items that suggest it is a law office

This essay is a sample of our Basic AI essay writer (Undergraduate 2:2 standard).

For guaranteed 2:1, First Class and Masters-level essays, register and top up your wallet.

Introduction

The traditional understanding of the separation of powers, derived from a Westminster model, posits that the legislature makes the law, the executive implements the law, and the judiciary interprets it. Within this framework, Parliament is often seen as the primary and most powerful law-making institution. However, this essay will argue that in the Zimbabwean legal system, the courts play a a more important and definitive role in shaping the actual content and substance of the law. While Parliament may pass statutes, it is the judiciary that gives these statutes meaning, ensures their constitutionality, and develops the vast body of common law. Through constitutional review, the development of common law, and the crucial function of statutory interpretation, the Zimbabwean courts are not merely passive interpreters but active shapers of the legal landscape. This essay will discuss these functions, using Zimbabwean case law to demonstrate the judiciary's significant impact on the law.

The Power of Constitutional Interpretation and Review

The most significant way in which the Zimbabwean judiciary shapes the law is through its power of constitutional review. The Constitution of Zimbabwe is the supreme law of the land, and any law or conduct inconsistent with it is invalid. It is the exclusive role of the courts to interpret and enforce the Constitution. This power allows the judiciary to scrutinise legislation passed by Parliament and to strike it down if it infringes upon the fundamental rights and freedoms enshrined in the Declaration of Rights. In doing so, the courts directly shape the boundaries of permissible law, acting as a final arbiter on the content of legislation.

A classic example of this power is the case of S v Ncube, S v Tshuma, S v Ndhlovu [1988] 1 ZLR 292 (S). In this case, the Supreme Court had to consider the constitutionality of corporal punishment for adults, which was permitted by the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act. The court held that the practice of whipping adults constituted inhuman and degrading punishment, which was prohibited by the Constitution. Consequently, the court struck down the relevant legislative provisions. This judgment did not merely interpret the law; it actively invalidated a law made by Parliament, thereby fundamentally changing the content of Zimbabwe’s criminal justice system. Parliament could pass a law, but the court determined its ultimate legality and content.

More recently, under the 2013 Constitution, the courts have continued this role. For example, in cases challenging restrictive media laws, the judiciary has been called upon to interpret the scope of freedom of expression. In Chavunduka & Anor v Minister of Home Affairs & Anor 2000 (1) ZLR 552 (S), the Supreme Court struck down a section of the Law and Order (Maintenance) Act that criminalised the publication of "false news". The court found it to be an unconstitutional violation of the right to freedom of expression because its wording was overly broad. By invalidating this statutory provision, the court directly shaped the law relating to media freedom, demonstrating that the legislature’s will is subordinate to the court's interpretation of the Constitution.

The Development of the Common Law

Beyond constitutional matters, a large portion of Zimbabwean law, particularly in private law areas such as delict (tort), contract, and property law, is not codified in statutes. This body of law is known as the common law, inherited from Roman-Dutch jurisprudence. The common law is almost entirely a product of judicial decisions. Judges do not simply apply existing rules; they adapt, extend, and sometimes create new principles on a case-by-case basis to meet the changing needs of society. This incremental development is a powerful form of law-making.

A clear illustration of this judicial function is the landmark case of Zimnat Insurance Co Ltd v Chawanda 1991 (2) SA 825 (ZS). The case concerned a widow in an unregistered customary law union who sued for loss of support following the death of her husband in a car accident. Under the old Roman-Dutch common law, a dependant’s action was only available to a spouse in a registered civil marriage. The Supreme Court, however, took a significant step by extending the action to include spouses in unregistered customary law unions, recognising them as a "solemn and binding" feature of Zimbabwean society.

In his judgment, Gubbay CJ stated that the common law must be adapted to reflect the "social conditions and mores of the people of Zimbabwe". This decision was a clear act of judicial activism. The court did not wait for Parliament to pass a statute to remedy the injustice; instead, it developed the common law to align it with contemporary social reality. This case powerfully demonstrates that in the absence of legislation, the courts are the primary architects of the law, shaping legal rights and obligations that affect the daily lives of citizens. The law on loss of support in Zimbabwe was not what it was before this judgment; the court had reshaped its content.

The Indispensable Role of Statutory Interpretation

Even where Parliament has legislated, a statute is not self-executing. The text of a statute is often open to multiple interpretations, and it falls to the judiciary to determine its precise meaning and scope. The process of statutory interpretation is far from a mechanical exercise; it is a creative function that gives definite shape to the abstract words of a statute. As noted by legal scholar Geoff Feltoe, the interpretation of statutes is a critical judicial function that can either broaden or narrow the effect of a legislative provision (Feltoe, 2010). The choice of interpretive approach—be it literal, purposive, or contextual—can lead to vastly different outcomes, effectively allowing the court to define the law's content.

For instance, when a statute is ambiguous, a court may adopt a purposive approach, seeking to give effect to the underlying purpose of the legislation. In doing so, the court is not simply discovering Parliament's intention but is constructing it based on legal principles and constitutional values. This is particularly important when interpreting laws that may impact fundamental rights. The courts will often "read down" or interpret a broad statutory provision narrowly to ensure it complies with the Constitution. This interpretive power means that the final content of any law is not what Parliament wrote, but what the courts say it means. Therefore, the legislative pen drafts the law, but the judicial voice gives it its final, authoritative content.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the role of Parliament as the primary legislative body cannot be dismissed, its power to define the final content of the law is significantly circumscribed by the judiciary. The courts in Zimbabwe play a more crucial role in shaping the law through three key functions. Firstly, through constitutional review, they act as the ultimate guardians of legality, with the power to invalidate laws that do not conform to the supreme law of the country. Secondly, they are the principal developers of the common law, adapting and creating legal principles to fit the evolving social context of Zimbabwe. Thirdly, through statutory interpretation, the judiciary determines the definitive meaning and application of laws passed by the legislature. Cases like S v Ncube and Zimnat Insurance v Chawanda are not anomalies but clear indicators of the judiciary's profound and active role in law-making. Therefore, it is the courts, not the legislature, that have the final and most important say on the substantive content of the law as it is applied and experienced by the people of Zimbabwe.

References

  • Chavunduka & Anor v Minister of Home Affairs & Anor 2000 (1) ZLR 552 (S).
  • Feltoe, G. (2010) A Guide to the Zimbabwean Law of Delict. 3rd edn. Harare: Legal Resources Foundation.
  • S v Ncube, S v Tshuma, S v Ndhlovu [1988] 1 ZLR 292 (S).
  • Zimnat Insurance Co Ltd v Chawanda 1991 (2) SA 825 (ZS).

Rate this essay:

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Written By

Essay Barrister

Recent essays:

Public law - photo of the houses of parliament

How long is too long? Delay in the magistrates' courts

The problem of delay in the criminal justice system raises important questions about fairness and efficiency. The case of Ms Adriana King in St ...
Read more: How long is too long? Delay in the magistrates' courts
Criminal law - a man snatching a handbag at gunpoint

The case for reform of the homicide offences

Introduction The law of homicide in England and Wales has been a subject of persistent criticism and debate for decades. The Law Commission’s assertion ...
Read more: The case for reform of the homicide offences

A Reflective Commentary on Advocacy in the County Court and the Court of Appeal

As the basis of my research and observation for this assignment, I have carefully attended a local court hearing at the Reading County Court, ...
Read more: A Reflective Commentary on Advocacy in the County Court and the Court of Appeal

Permission to approach the inbox?

Helpful legal writing guidance, AI updates, free credits and exclusive offers, delivered occasionally and respectfully. No spam, no waffle, no abuse of process.