SEE LATEST ESSAYS English legal system and legal method essays

A Reflective Commentary on Advocacy in the County Court and the Court of Appeal

Essay Barrister
November 20, 2026
No comments

This essay is a sample of our Basic AI essay writer (Undergraduate 2:2 standard).

For guaranteed 2:1, First Class and Masters-level essays, register and top up your wallet.

As the basis of my research and observation for this assignment, I have carefully attended a local court hearing at the Reading County Court, specifically a fast-track civil trial in the case of *Davies v Premier Builders Ltd*, and studied an appellate hearing from the English Court of Appeal, *Currie v Soho Theatre Co Ltd*. Both proceedings were civil matters, but their purpose and procedures were fundamentally different, which was reflected in the style of advocacy employed by the lawyers. The County Court case was a first-instance trial concerned with establishing facts, whereas the Court of Appeal operated as a court of review, examining whether the original judge had made an error in law. My observations of how lawyers performed in these two distinct settings highlight the different skills required of advocates at different levels of the English legal system.

Local Court Observation: Reading County Court

In the case of *Davies v Premier Builders Ltd*, the hearing was a physical trial before a single District Judge. The matter concerned a contractual dispute over alleged defective building work at the claimant’s property. The claimant was represented by a junior barrister, and the defendant company’s director was representing the company himself as a litigant in person. The primary function of this hearing was to hear evidence from both sides to establish the facts of what happened.

What struck me about the advocacy of the claimant’s barrister was how it was entirely focused on building a factual narrative supported by documentary evidence and witness testimony. Her style was methodical and based on forensic examination of the details. I noticed this most clearly during her cross-examination of the defendant. She used a series of short, closed questions to challenge the defendant’s version of events. For example, the defendant had claimed that all electrical work was completed by a certain date. The barrister directed him to an invoice he himself had submitted, asking him to confirm the date on it, which was two weeks later than the date he had just given in his testimony. She then asked him to read aloud an entry on the invoice which stated “Final testing and certification of wiring”. She followed this with a simple, powerful question: “So the work was not, in fact, complete on the date you told the court, was it?”. This technique was not about arguing complex law but about using the other side’s own documents to dismantle their credibility piece by piece in front of the judge. It was a practical and evidence-driven approach.

Court of Appeal Observation: *Currie v Soho Theatre Co Ltd*

In the appeal of *Currie v Soho Theatre Co Ltd*, the setting and method of advocacy were entirely different. The hearing was conducted before two senior judges, Lord Justice Warby and Lady Justice Asplin. The case concerned an appeal on a point of law from the Employment Appeal Tribunal relating to a claim of indirect disability discrimination under the Equality Act 2010. The appellant, Mr Currie, was represented by Mr David Hurst, and the respondent, Soho Theatre, was represented by Mr Gervase de Wilde. There were no witnesses and no new evidence was presented.

Mr Hurst’s advocacy for the appellant was what I would describe as a formal legal debate with the judges. His task was to persuade the court that the lower tribunal had misinterpreted the law. What struck me was that his carefully prepared submissions were almost immediately interrupted by questions from the bench. For example, very early in his argument, Lord Justice Warby intervened to ask for clarification on how Mr Hurst was defining the ‘provision, criterion or practice’ (PCP) that was alleged to be discriminatory. This led to a prolonged exchange where Mr Hurst had to defend his legal formulation against the judge’s probing. His advocacy was less about giving a speech and more about engaging in a high-level dialogue, constantly having to adapt his argument in response to judicial questioning. He referred the judges constantly to paragraphs in authorities and the original judgment, showing that his entire focus was on legal text and interpretation.

Similarly, Mr de Wilde’s role for the respondent was to defend the original judgment. His advocacy was primarily responsive, both to Mr Hurst’s arguments and to the judges’ concerns. Lady Justice Asplin, for instance, posed a hypothetical question to him about the wider implications of the theatre’s policy, asking what should happen if a performer’s actions cause distress to a vulnerable audience member. Mr de Wilde’s advocacy here was about reassuring the court that the original judgment was not only legally correct but also practical and just in its consequences. His skill was in thinking on his feet and framing his answers to address the specific legal anxieties of the judges.

Differences in Advocacy and Surprising Aspects

The primary difference in advocacy between the County Court and the Court of Appeal was its focus. The County Court barrister was concerned with *facts*, using evidence to prove *what happened*. The Court of Appeal barristers were concerned with *law*, using legal authorities to argue *what the law means*. This meant the skills on display were different. The local court barrister needed to be skilled in cross-examination and managing evidence. The appellate barristers needed to be masters of legal principle and skilled in academic-style debate.

What surprised me most was the nature of the interaction between the lawyers and the judges in the Court of Appeal. I had expected a more passive bench, listening to long arguments. Instead, the hearing was an active, dynamic conversation. The judges were not just listening; they were testing, challenging, and probing the arguments from the very beginning. This made the hearing feel more like a university seminar than the adversarial contest I had witnessed in the County Court. It was surprising to see how collaborative the process of exploring the law seemed to be, even though the two sides were in opposition.

Another surprising element was the level of preparation and pre-reading done by the appeal judges. Their immediate and detailed questions showed they had an absolute command of the case facts and the legal issues before the hearing even began. In the County Court, the judge was learning the facts as the evidence was presented. In the Court of Appeal, the judges already knew the history of the case and were there only to be persuaded on discreet points of law. This fundamental difference explains why the advocacy in each court is, and must be, so profoundly different.

References

  • Currie v The Soho Theatre Company Ltd [2023] EAT 143

Rate this essay:

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Written By

Essay Barrister

Recent essays:

Public law - photo of the houses of parliament

How long is too long? Delay in the magistrates' courts

The problem of delay in the criminal justice system raises important questions about fairness and efficiency. The case of Ms Adriana King in St ...
Read more: How long is too long? Delay in the magistrates' courts
Criminal law - a man snatching a handbag at gunpoint

The case for reform of the homicide offences

Introduction The law of homicide in England and Wales has been a subject of persistent criticism and debate for decades. The Law Commission’s assertion ...
Read more: The case for reform of the homicide offences

A Reflective Commentary on Advocacy in the County Court and the Court of Appeal

As the basis of my research and observation for this assignment, I have carefully attended a local court hearing at the Reading County Court, ...
Read more: A Reflective Commentary on Advocacy in the County Court and the Court of Appeal

Permission to approach the inbox?

Helpful legal writing guidance, AI updates, free credits and exclusive offers, delivered occasionally and respectfully. No spam, no waffle, no abuse of process.